Alaí’s Broadside: Orengo, Sifuna, Babu Accused of Clinging to Past Glory as Kenya Moves On

ODM Member of County Assembly Robert Alai has sharply criticized a section of Kenya’s political class, accusing several well-known figures of hindering progress and clinging to outdated ideologies. 

In his remarks, he described them as “hostages of history,” arguing that their influence is preventing the country from fully adapting to present-day political realities.

Alai specifically referenced leaders such as Edwin Sifuna, James Orengo, and Babu Owino, as well as long-standing activists and political commentators.

He contends that individuals who rose to prominence during the pro-democracy struggles of the 1980s and 1990s have struggled to adjust to the demands of modern governance. 

According to him, their continued dependence on liberation-era narratives has positioned them as barriers to innovation, often dismissing emerging leaders and new perspectives.

A key element of his argument is that some of these figures portray themselves as ethical authorities while simultaneously sidelining fresh voices. 

He views this as a contradiction, suggesting that individuals who once championed democratic freedoms are now accused of restricting them by dominating political discourse and resisting change.

Alai also addressed debates surrounding Raila Odinga’s legacy, criticizing what he sees as double standards among certain analysts. 

He claimed that while some commentators fault others for interpreting Odinga’s views, they also present themselves as definitive voices on his political legacy. 

In his view, this reflects a broader culture of selective criticism and self-appointment within Kenya’s political space.

On matters of governance, Alai singled out James Orengo’s tenure as Siaya Governor, questioning his effectiveness. 

He argued that Orengo appears to have had difficulty transitioning from activism to administrative leadership, alleging that continued engagement in national political disputes detracts from his county responsibilities.

Extending his critique further, Alai suggested that some veteran activists have become entrenched in rigid thinking, limiting their ability to embrace new ideas. 

He warned that such stagnation risks turning activism into personal branding rather than a vehicle for meaningful reform.

Ultimately, Alai called for generational renewal, urging that Kenya’s future should be shaped by new leadership and contemporary movements. 

While acknowledging the importance of past contributions, he emphasized that they should not overshadow the need for forward-looking governance focused on practical solutions rather than nostalgia.